BlueCollarBench

Trades/HVAC

HVACTask HV-016masterKnowledgeUS

Doing a combustion analysis on a 90+ condensing furnace.

Prompt as given to every model

Doing a combustion analysis on a 90+ condensing furnace. What readings am I looking for and which number is the stop-the-job number?

Model answers

Pick up to two to compare side by side. Score chips fill in as the judge grades.

Laguna S 2.1Score —

Key Readings for 90+ Condensing Furnace Combustion Analysis:

  1. Oxygen (O₂): Target 2-4% (condensing furnaces operate with excess air).
  2. Carbon Monoxide (CO): Must be <50 ppm (ideally <10 ppm) in undiluted stack gas.
  3. Carbon Dioxide (CO₂): Typically 8-10% for natural gas.
  4. Stack Temperature: Should be <125°F (ideally 90-110°F) for high efficiency.
  5. Efficiency: Should be ≥90% (as rated).
  6. Draft/Pressure: Negative draft in combustion chamber; vent should be neutral to slightly negative.

Stop-the-Job Numbers (Unsafe Conditions):

  • CO > 50 ppm in stack gas (immediate hazard).
  • O₂ > 15% or <1% (indicates combustion air issues).
  • Stack temp > 200°F (possible heat exchanger breach or improper venting).
  • Visible soot or rollout at heat exchanger (safety hazard).

Code Reference: Per NFPA 54 (2020), Section 7.11, CO in occupied spaces must not exceed 35 ppm (8-hour exposure). For stack CO, ANSI Z21.45 requires <50 ppm for gas appliances.

Action: If any stop-the-job number is hit, shut down the furnace, ventilate, and investigate (e.g., cracked heat exchanger, blocked vent, or improper gas pressure). Retest after corrections.

452 tokens · 305.0s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.

Nemotron 3 Ultra 550BScore —

Target Readings (High Fire, after 5–10 min run time):

| Parameter | Target Range | Code/Standard Ref | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | O₂ | 4.5% – 6.5% (≈ 8.5%–9.5% CO₂) | NFPA 54 / ANSI Z223.1; Mfr specs | | CO (air-free) | < 100 ppm (Ideally < 50 ppm) | AHRI Guideline X; NFPA 54 §10.1.1 | | CO/CO₂ Ratio | < 0.008 (0.8%) | AHRI Guideline X | | Stack Temp | 80°F – 120°F (must be < 140°F to condense) | Mfr specs; Condensing physics | | Draft/Pressure | Positive (per mfr, typically +0.05” to +0.20” w.c.) | Mfr install manual | | ΔT (Supply-Return) | 35°F – 65°F (check nameplate rise range) | Mfr specs; ACCA Manual S |


🛑 STOP-THE-JOB NUMBERS (Shut down immediately):

  1. CO (air-free) > 400 ppmImmediate hazard. (AHRI Guideline X / NFPA 54 §10.1.1).
  2. CO (as-measured) > 100 ppm in flue with O₂ < 3% — Indicates severe rich burn/flame impingement.
  3. Flue Gas Spillage / Negative Draft on a Category I/II/IV appliance not designed for it — CO entering CAZ.
  4. Stack Temp > 140°F on a 90%+ unit — Not condensing; heat exchanger fouled, over-fired, or airflow critically low.
  5. CO in Supply Air > 9 ppm (ambient limit) or any CO detected in living space — Cracked HX or backdrafting.

Critical Workflow:

  1. Zero analyzer in fresh air.
  2. Clock gas meter — verify input = nameplate ±2%. Wrong input invalidates all other readings.
  3. Test High Fire first (worst case for CO).
  4. Test Low Fire — CO often spikes here on modulating units.
  5. Measure combustion air at burner inlet (O₂ ~20.9%). If < 20.5%, solve air starvation first.
  6. Adjust gas valve only if O₂/CO₂ off spec and input clocked correct. Adjust in 1/8-turn increments. Re-clock after adjustment.

If CO > 100 ppm air-free: Check gas pressure, primary air, burner alignment, HX blockage, venting. Do not leave running.

781 tokens · 9.7s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.