BlueCollarBench

Trades/Landscaping & Site Work

Landscaping & Site WorkTask LA-029journeymanCatchFL

Mid-July, Jacksonville.

Prompt as given to every model

Mid-July, Jacksonville. Sod supplier dropped 10 pallets of Floratam on Friday afternoon; crew laid it Monday and Tuesday, ran the irrigation once Tuesday evening after finishing, then set the controller for the address's two allowed days. By Friday it's yellow and the edges are curling. What went wrong?

Model answers

Pick up to two to compare side by side. Score chips fill in as the judge grades.

Nemotron 3 Ultra 550BScore —

Primary failure: Insufficient water during establishment. Floratam (St. Augustine) in Jacksonville in mid-July requires daily irrigation for the first 10–14 days—often twice daily for the first 3–5 days—to keep the soil and sod layer continuously moist until roots peg down. One watering Tuesday evening + two scheduled days is nowhere near enough; the sod desiccated before root initiation.

Contributing factors

  • Friday–Monday sit time: Pallets left 72 hrs in July heat likely arrived heat-stressed/dry. Should have been laid same-day or unstacked/shaded/watered on pallets.
  • No “establishment” program: Florida Water Management Districts (e.g., SJRWMD 40C-2) allow daily watering for 30 days for new sod, regardless of address restrictions. The controller should have been set to “New Lawn”/“Establishment” schedule, not the permanent 2-day schedule.
  • No verification: Crew didn’t check soil moisture (probe or screwdriver test) under corners daily.

Immediate remediation

  1. Switch controller to daily start times (2–3 cycles/day, 10–15 min each) for the next 10 days; verify coverage with catch cans.
  2. Hand-water curled edges and hot spots mid-day.
  3. Apply light N (0.25 lb N/1,000 ft²) once green-up resumes; avoid herbicides.
  4. Document watering logs & photos for supplier warranty claim—pallet sit time may void it.

Code/Reference: UF/IFAS ENH11 “Establishing Your Florida Lawn”; SJRWMD 40C-2.301(2)(b) establishment exemption.

521 tokens · 11.5s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.

Nemotron 3 Super 120BScore —

The sod is showing signs of severe stress—yellowing and curling edges—due to inadequate irrigation during establishment, compounded by hot, dry conditions in mid-July Jacksonville.

What went wrong:

  1. Insufficient initial watering: New sod requires frequent, light irrigation to keep the root zone moist (not soggy) for the first 7–10 days. After laying sod Monday–Tuesday, only one irrigation event was applied Tuesday evening. That’s far too little. In Jacksonville’s summer heat (highs 90°F+, humidity high but evaporation rapid), sod can dry out in 24 hours without water.
  1. Controller set to “two allowed days” too soon: Setting the controller to the municipality’s twice-weekly limit immediately after installation violates establishment needs. New sod needs 2–4 short cycles per day (5–10 mins each) for the first week, then gradually taper. The twice-weekly schedule is for established lawns, not new sod.
  1. No moisture monitoring: No mention of checking soil moisture or sod adhesion. Curling edges = wilting from drought stress. Yellowing = early-stage root death or desiccation.

Corrective action (if not too late):

  • Immediately increase irrigation to 2–3 times daily (early morning, midday, late afternoon) for 5–10 mins per zone, just enough to wet the top 1–2 inches of soil.
  • Avoid flooding—promotes rot and wastes water.
  • Check for rooting: gently lift a corner after 3–4 days; if roots are white and penetrating soil, recovery is possible. If brown and dry, sod is dead.
  • Do not fertilize or mow until sod is firmly rooted (usually 2–3 weeks).

Prevention for next time:

  • Irrigate new sod 2–4x/day for first 7–10 days, then reduce frequency, increase depth.
  • Follow UF/IFAS Extension guidelines: https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/EP236
  • If watering restrictions apply, request a temporary variance for new sod installation (many Florida utilities allow this with proof of installation date).

Bottom line: The sod died from drought stress due to mismatched irrigation scheduling. New sod ≠ established lawn. Adjust watering to match plant needs, not just code limits. If >50% is brown, replacement is likely needed. (Word count: 248)

684 tokens · 3.9s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.