BlueCollarBench

Trades/Masonry & Concrete

Masonry & ConcreteTask MA-017journeymanKnowledgeUS

How do I size a footing for a one-story CMU house on sand?

Prompt as given to every model

How do I size a footing for a one-story CMU house on sand? I don't have an engineer on this one.

Model answers

Pick up to two to compare side by side. Score chips fill in as the judge grades.

Nemotron 3 Ultra 550BScore —

Do not proceed without a licensed structural engineer. Sizing footings on sand for a CMU structure involves geotechnical variables (bearing capacity, settlement, water table, liquefaction potential) that cannot be determined by rule of thumb. The IRC does not provide prescriptive footing tables for sand without a soils report (IRC R401.4.1).

Why this fails prescriptively:

  1. Soil Bearing Capacity: "Sand" ranges from 1,500 psf (loose) to 6,000+ psf (dense). You cannot guess this.
  2. Settlement: Sand settles immediately under load. Differential settlement cracks CMU walls irreversibly.
  3. IRC R403.1.1: Requires footings to be sized per Table R403.1(1) based on load-bearing value of soil (psf) determined by a geotechnical investigation.
  4. CMU Specifics: Concentrated loads at bond beams, lintels, and roof bearings require wider footings or pilasters than wood-frame walls.

Minimum steps to get a permit/design:

  1. Hire a Geotechnical Engineer for a soils report (borings, SPT N-values, recommended allowable bearing pressure).
  2. Hire a Structural Engineer to calculate loads (Dead + Live + Snow/Wind/Seismic per ASCE 7) and size footings (Width, Depth, Reinforcement) per ACI 318 / TMS 402.
  3. Typical minimums (for budgeting only, not construction): Depth: 12" min below undisturbed grade (IRC R403.1.4), deeper for frost/flood. Width: Often 16"–24" for 8" CMU on decent sand (2,000+ psf), but highly variable. * Rebar: (2) #4 continuous bottom min (IRC R403.1.3.5.1), usually more for CMU shear walls.

Liability: If this settles or cracks, you own the repair. The cost of an engineer ($1.5k–$3k) is <1% of the foundation replacement cost.

592 tokens · 15.2s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.

Nemotron 3 Super 120BScore —

You should not size a footing for a one-story CMU house on sand without a licensed professional engineer or architect. Here’s why, and what you can do:

⚠️ Critical Safety Note:

Footing design requires geotechnical and structural analysis. Sand soil bearing capacity varies widely (typically 1,000–3,000 psf for loose to medium dense sand), but you cannot assume it’s adequate without a soil test. CMU (concrete masonry unit) walls are heavy and brittle — uneven settlement can cause cracking, structural failure, or collapse. This is not a DIY task.

What You Must Do:

  1. Get a Soil Report Hire a geotechnical engineer to perform a borehole test and provide an allowable soil bearing pressure (in psf). This is required by IBC Section 1803 and IRC R401.4 for all foundations.
  1. Calculate Footing Size (Once You Have Soil Data) Use this simplified formula for a continuous wall footing (per IRC Table R403.1(1) and R403.1.1): `` Footing Width (in) = (Wall Load + Live Load) ÷ (Allowable Soil Bearing Pressure) × 12 ` - Typical one-story CMU wall load: ~800–1,200 plf (pounds per linear foot) including roof, floor, and wall self-weight. - Example: If soil bearing = 2,000 psf and wall load = 1,000 plf: Width = (1,000 plf) / (2,000 psf) × 12 = 6 inches` → Minimum 8" wide footing (per IRC R403.1.1, min. 8" for concrete footings). - Depth: Minimum 12" below undisturbed soil (IRC R403.1.4), but must extend below frost line if applicable (check local code).
  1. Reinforcement CMU footings typically require #4 rebar at 12" o.c. both ways (top and bottom) per ACI 318 and IRC R403.1.3 — do not skip this.

✅ Action Steps:

  • Stop DIY sizing.
  • Contact a local geotechnical engineer ($300–$800 for a basic soil test on a small lot).
  • Submit the report to your building department — they will require it for a permit.
  • Have a structural engineer or licensed contractor design the footing using the soil data.

🚫 Never:

  • Guess soil bearing capacity.
  • Use “rule of thumb” like “2x wall width” — it’s unsafe and code-noncompliant.
  • Pour footings without inspection or permit.

Bottom line: Sand can be deceptive — it may look solid but settle unevenly under load. One story

781 tokens · 9.4s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.