BlueCollarBench

Trades/Roofing

RoofingTask RO-028masterCodeFL

Florida shingle reroof on a 5:12, 130 mph zone.

Prompt as given to every model

Florida shingle reroof on a 5:12, 130 mph zone. What underlayment/secondary water barrier options does the code actually allow, and how does it get fastened?

Model answers

Pick up to two to compare side by side. Score chips fill in as the judge grades.

Nemotron 3 Ultra 550BScore —

Code Basis: 2023 FBC-R (R905.1.1, R905.2.7, R905.2.8.3) & FBC-B (1507.1.1, 1507.2.7). HVHZ (Miami-Dade/Broward) has stricter rules—below assumes non-HVHZ.

Allowed Underlayment/Secondary Water Barrier (SWB) Options

For 5:12 slope in 130 mph (Exposure B/C), you need a Self-Adhering Polymer-Modified Bitumen (SAPMB) membrane complying with ASTM D1970 as your SWB. This satisfies both the underlayment and the SWB requirement (R905.2.7.1).

  • Option A (Standard): Single layer ASTM D1970 over entire roof deck. No felt/paper needed underneath or on top.
  • Option B (Two-Layer): ASTM D226 Type II (No. 30 felt) or ASTM D4869 Type IV fastened per Table R905.2.7.1(1) + ASTM D1970 applied over all eaves, rakes, valleys, hips, ridges, penetrations, and wall intersections (min. 36" wide sheets, 6" laps). Option A is faster and cheaper labor-wise.

Prohibited: Synthetic "roofing underlayments" (ASTM D8257) cannot serve as the SWB in 130 mph zones. They are only approved as underlayment beneath a separate SWB (Option B) or on slopes ≥ 2:12 in lower wind zones.

Fastening Requirements (Critical for 130 mph)

For ASTM D1970 (Option A): Mechanical fasteners are REQUIRED in addition to self-adhesion.

  • Fastener: Cap nails (min. 1" cap) or cap staples (min. 1" crown, 16 ga.).
  • Penetration: Min. ¾" into deck or through deck thickness.
  • Pattern (R905.2.7.1 / Table R905.2.7.1(1)):
  • Field: 12" o.c. max (staggered rows).
  • Laps (Side & End): 6" o.c. max (staggered from field pattern).
  • Edges (Eaves/Rakes): 6" o.c. max.
  • Deck: Must be solid 15/32" plywood/OSB (R905.2.1). No skip sheathing.

For Felt (Option B base layer): Cap nails/staples 12" o.c. field, 6" o.c. edges/laps (Table R905.2.7.1(1)). Then roll D1970 over it (self-adhered only, no extra caps needed

798 tokens · 12.4s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.

Nemotron 3 Super 120BScore —

For a Florida shingle reroof on a 5:12 slope in a 130 mph wind zone (likely Wind Zone 2 or 3 per FBC), the Florida Building Code (FBC), 8th Edition (2023), governs underlayment and secondary water barrier (SWB) requirements.

Allowed Underlayment Options (FBC R905.1.1, R905.2.8.2):

  • Asphalt-saturated felt: Minimum #15 (ASTM D226 Type I) or #30 (Type II).
  • Synthetic underlayment: Must comply with ASTM D226, D4869, or D6757 and be listed for use under asphalt shingles (e.g., GAF Deck Armor, Owens Corning Syntech).
  • Self-adhering polymer-modified bitumen: Allowed as primary underlayment in high-wind zones if tested per ASTM D1970 and listed for the application.

Secondary Water Barrier (SWB) Requirements (FBC R905.1.1, R905.2.8.2, R905.2.8.3):

Required in High Velocity Hurricane Zone (HVHZ) — which includes Miami-Dade and Broward Counties — and strongly recommended (often required by local amendment) in 130 mph zones outside HVHZ for reroofing.

Allowed SWB Options (FBC R905.2.8.2):

  1. Self-adhering modified bitumen membrane (e.g., Grace Ice & Water Shield, GAF WeatherWatch): - Must be applied directly to the roof deck. - Minimum 6-inch overlap at seams. - Fastened only at laps if required by manufacturer (typically self-sealing; no fasteners needed in field). - Critical: Must be continuous over sheathing joints and extend at least 6 inches up vertical surfaces (walls, chimneys).
  1. Alternative: Two layers of approved underlayment (e.g., #30 felt + synthetic) may be accepted as SWB in some jurisdictions if installed per manufacturer’s high-wind application — but verify with local building department. Self-adhering membrane is the most reliable and widely accepted method.

Fastening (FBC R905.2.8.2, R905.2.8.3):

  • Self-adhering SWB: No fasteners in the field — adhesion to clean, dry, primed deck is sufficient. Fasteners only at terminations (e.g., top edge under flashing) if specified by manufacturer.
  • Underlayment (if used as SWB alternative):
  • #15/#30 felt: Minimum 1-inch crown staples or 11-gauge roofing nails, spaced max 6” o.c. at edges and 12” o.c. in field (FBC Table R905.1.1(2)).
  • Synthetic: Follow manufacturer’s high-wind fastening pattern (often 6”/12
798 tokens · 21.1s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.