BlueCollarBench

Trades/Plumbing

PlumbingTask PL-026journeymanCodeUS

Installing a gas tank water heater in an attached garage.

Prompt as given to every model

Installing a gas tank water heater in an attached garage. What does code say about height and the pan?

Model answers

Pick up to two to compare side by side. Score chips fill in as the judge grades.

Nemotron 3 Ultra 550BScore —

IRC 2021/2024 (M1305, G2408, P2801) & IFGC 2021/2024:

1. Ignition Source Height (Critical for Garages):

  • Rule: All burners, pilot lights, and ignition sources must be ≥ 18 inches above the garage floor (IRC M1305.1.3 / IFGC 305.3).
  • Application: Measure from the garage floor to the bottom of the burner/ignition assembly, not the bottom of the tank. Most standard "tall" 40/50-gal heaters on a standard 2–3" stand meet this. Short/"Lowboy" models often fail. Verify spec sheet "height to burner" dimension before buying.

2. Elevation/Stand:

  • Code does not mandate a specific stand height, only the 18" ignition clearance.
  • Practice: Use a listed, corrosion-resistant metal stand (often 18" or 24") or a code-approved masonry/concrete platform. Wood platforms are prohibited in garages (IRC M1305.1.3 exception). Secure heater to stand/straps per seismic zone (IRC M1307.2).

3. Drain Pan (IRC P2801.5 / IFGC 504.4):

  • Required: Yes, because an attached garage is "where damage from leakage may occur."
  • Material: Min. 24-gauge galvanized steel, 0.025" aluminum, or 0.0625" plastic (PVC/CPVC).
  • Size: ≥ 1.5" deep; diameter ≥ heater diameter + 2" (catch all condensate/leaks).
  • Drain Line: Min. ¾" ID pipe (PVC, CPVC, copper, steel). Must terminate to an approved location: floor drain, laundry tray, or outside the building (IRC P2801.5.2). Terminating onto the garage floor is a violation. Slope ¼"/ft. No trap required at pan, but protect terminus from freezing/blockage.

4. Gas Shutoff & Sediment Trap:

  • Sediment trap (drip leg) required at heater inlet (IFGC 408.4).
  • Accessible gas shutoff valve within 6 ft of appliance (IFGC 409.5).

5. Combustion Air:

  • Garages usually qualify as "unconfined space" (volume > 50 ft³/1000 BTU/hr). If confined, provide high/low vents per IFGC 304.

Verify: Local amendments often adopt IRC/IFGC with modifications. Pull permit; inspector has final say.

723 tokens · 5.8s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.

Nemotron 3 Super 120BScore —

When installing a gas tank water heater in an attached garage, the International Residential Code (IRC) and International Mechanical Code (IMC) set specific requirements for height and drainage pans to ensure safety and prevent damage from leaks or flooding.

Height Requirement (IRC M1307.3 / IMC 504.6): The ignition source (e.g., pilot light, burner, or electric ignition) of a gas-fired water heater installed in a garage must be at least 18 inches above the garage floor. This minimizes the risk of igniting gasoline vapors, which tend to accumulate near the floor. Note: This applies to the ignition source, not necessarily the bottom of the tank. However, most standard gas water heaters have their burner assembly near the bottom, so the unit is typically elevated on a stand to meet this 18-inch minimum.

Drain Pan Requirement (IRC P2801.6 / IMC 504.7): If the water heater is installed in a location where leakage could cause damage (including an attached garage), a drain pan must be provided beneath the tank. The pan must:

  • Be made of corrosion-resistant material (e.g., galvanized steel, plastic).
  • Have a minimum depth of 1.5 inches.
  • Be drained by an indirect waste pipe discharging to a floor drain, exterior, or other approved location (not directly into the sewer).
  • If no drain is available, the pan must have a drain line that terminates where it will not cause damage (e.g., to the exterior, at least 6 inches above ground and not over a walkway).

Additional Notes:

  • The pan must be large enough to catch all condensate and leakage (typically extends at least 2 inches beyond the heater’s footprint).
  • Local amendments may vary—always check with your AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction).
  • If the garage is not used for vehicle storage, some jurisdictions may allow exceptions, but the 18-inch ignition height and pan requirements still apply in most cases for attached garages due to potential vapor accumulation and leakage risk.

Bottom Line: Elevate the heater so the ignition source is ≥18" above the floor, and install a code-compliant drain pan with proper drainage. When in doubt, consult a licensed plumber or your local building department.

(Word count: 248)

596 tokens · 14.0s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.