BlueCollarBench

Trades/Plumbing

PlumbingTask PL-030apprenticeCatchUS

Under a slab, a helper joined a 3-inch horizontal branch into the 4-inch horizontal building drain with a 4x3 sanitary tee laid on its back, because 'that's what fit.' Inspection is tomorrow.

Prompt as given to every model

Under a slab, a helper joined a 3-inch horizontal branch into the 4-inch horizontal building drain with a 4x3 sanitary tee laid on its back, because 'that's what fit.' Inspection is tomorrow. What's wrong?

Model answers

Pick up to two to compare side by side. Score chips fill in as the judge grades.

Nemotron 3 Ultra 550BScore —

It is a prohibited fitting orientation. A sanitary tee (san-tee) cannot be installed on its back (horizontal-to-horizontal) for drainage. It creates a 90° directional change without the required sweep radius, causing blockages and violating the fundamental "no 90s on the horizontal" rule.

Code Violation (IPC 706.3 / UPC 706.0):

  • Sanitary Tees: Permitted only for vertical-to-horizontal (branch to stack) or vertical-to-vertical connections.
  • Horizontal-to-Horizontal: Requires a Wye (Y) or Combination Wye & 1/8 Bend (Long Turn). A 4x3 Wye or 4x3 Combo is the correct fitting here.

Why "It fit" is wrong: A san-tee on its back has a sharp 90° interior corner. Solids stall there. A Wye directs flow at 45°; a Combo adds a long-radius sweep.

The Fix (Do this today):

  1. Cut out the san-tee and the short piece of 3" pipe connected to it.
  2. Install a 4x3 Wye (or Combo) on the 4" drain. Ensure the branch inlet is at 45° (not rolled up).
  3. Reconnect the 3" branch using a 45° ell if needed to align, maintaining 1/4" per foot fall.
  4. Support the new fittings per code (typically every 4 ft for 3"/4" PVC/ABS).

If the 3" branch is a vent: A san-tee on its back is also wrong for a dry vent takeoff (requires Wye or 45°). If it's a wet vent, same fix applies.

Bottom line: Inspector will red-tag this. Replace with a 4x3 Wye (or Combo) now.

541 tokens · 10.4s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.

Nemotron 3 Super 120BScore —

The installation is not code-compliant and will likely fail inspection.

What’s wrong: A 4×3 sanitary tee laid on its back (i.e., with the branch inlet horizontal and the main run horizontal) creates an improper fitting orientation for a horizontal-to-horizontal connection. Sanitary tees are designed for vertical-to-horizontal connections (e.g., a vertical stack receiving a horizontal branch). When laid on its back, the fitting’s internal sweep and flow dynamics are disrupted, increasing the risk of:

  • Solids trapping in the branch inlet due to poor flow transition.
  • Self-siphonage or trap seal loss from inadequate venting dynamics.
  • Blockage potential from debris catching on the sharp internal corner of the tee’s branch opening.

Code reference (IPC 2021 / UPC 2021):

  • IPC 704.1: Requires fittings to be installed in accordance with their listing and manufacturer’s instructions. Sanitary tees are not listed for horizontal-to-horizontal use.
  • IPC 704.2: Prohibits the use of sanitary tees for connections where the flow direction is horizontal into horizontal — only wye fittings (45°) or long-turn elbows are permitted for such transitions.
  • IPC 903.1: Requires drainage fittings to maintain a minimum 1/4" per foot slope and avoid creating traps or obstructions.

Correct fix: Replace the sanitary tee with a 4×3 wye (45°) fitting, properly oriented with the branch inlet flowing into the main drain in the direction of flow. If space is tight, use a long-turn 90° elbow with a reducer bushing or a sanitary tee with a street elbow — but never lay a sanitary tee on its back for horizontal-to-horizontal flow.

Action: Remove the fitting tonight and install a proper wye. Inspection will likely reject this — it’s a common violation. Do not rely on “it fit” — code governs function, not convenience. (If unsure, consult a licensed plumber — this is a drainage system defect risk.)

607 tokens · 11.7s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.