BlueCollarBench

Trades/Plumbing

PlumbingTask PL-039masterCatchUS

Restaurant build-out: the plumber hard-piped the 3-compartment sink with a P-trap straight into the branch feeding the grease interceptor, ran the ice machine drain and the prep sink directly into the sanitary line with traps, and set the walk-in cooler floor drain with a trap inside the box.

Prompt as given to every model

Restaurant build-out: the plumber hard-piped the 3-compartment sink with a P-trap straight into the branch feeding the grease interceptor, ran the ice machine drain and the prep sink directly into the sanitary line with traps, and set the walk-in cooler floor drain with a trap inside the box. Health and plumbing inspection is Friday. What gets flagged?

Model answers

Pick up to two to compare side by side. Score chips fill in as the judge grades.

Nemotron 3 Ultra 550BScore —

Multiple code violations. Do not expect to pass Friday.

  1. 3-Compartment Sink → Grease Interceptor Branch (No Indirect Waste): Violation: IPC 802.1.1 / UPC 801.2. Food prep sinks require an indirect waste connection (air gap). Hard-piping directly into the GI branch line is prohibited. It allows grease/solids to bypass the interceptor's retention design and risks backflow contamination. Fix: Install a floor sink or hub drain with an air gap (min. 2x pipe diameter, 1" min) between the sink tailpiece and the GI inlet piping.
  1. Ice Machine Drain → Sanitary (Direct Connection): Violation: IPC 802.1.1 / UPC 801.2. Ice machines are food equipment requiring an indirect waste (air gap). Direct connection risks sewage backup contaminating the ice supply. Fix: Route drain to a floor sink/hub drain with a proper air gap. Note: Condensate from the head unit may go direct if allowed by local amendment, but the bin drain never does.
  1. Prep Sink → Sanitary (Direct Connection): Violation: IPC 802.1.1 / UPC 801.2. Prep sinks are food prep fixtures. Indirect waste (air gap) required.* Direct trapped connection is illegal.
  1. Walk-In Cooler Floor Drain → Trap Inside Box: Violation: IPC 1002.4 / UPC 1007.1. Traps subject to freezing (inside a cooler/freezer) are prohibited. The trap seal will freeze and crack, or evaporate, losing the seal. Fix: Run the drain line untrapped from the cooler floor drain to a trapped floor sink/hub drain located in the conditioned kitchen space (indirect waste receptor). The receptor trap provides the seal.

Summary for Plumber: Move all four fixture drains to indirect waste receptors (floor sinks/hub drains) in the kitchen with code-compliant air gaps. Remove the trap from inside the walk-in. This requires re-piping.

639 tokens · 33.9s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.

Nemotron 3 Super 120BScore —

Several issues will likely be flagged during inspection. Here’s what’s non-compliant per the International Plumbing Code (IPC) and typical health department requirements:

  1. 3-compartment sink drain to grease interceptor without proper venting or indirect waste - The IPC § 704.1 requires indirect waste for fixtures discharging into grease interceptors unless the interceptor is designed for direct connection (rare). - A hard-piped P-trap discharging directly into the branch line feeding the grease interceptor is not allowed. The sink must discharge via an air break or air gap into a floor sink or receptor that then drains to the interceptor (IPC § 802.3.2). - Flagged: Direct connection violates indirect waste rule; risk of backflow and contamination.
  1. Ice machine drain and prep sink connected directly to sanitary line - Ice machine drains must be indirect (IPC § 802.3.1) — typically via an air gap into a floor sink. Direct connection risks contaminating potable water or creating cross-connection hazards. - Prep sinks (if used for food washing) also typically require indirect waste per health codes (e.g., FDA Food Code § 5-203.11) to prevent backflow. - Flagged: Both are likely direct connections — violation of indirect waste requirements for food-related equipment.
  1. *Walk-in cooler floor drain with trap inside the box - IPC § 1002.1 requires traps to be accessible for maintenance. A trap inside the cooler box is not accessible without entering the unit — violates accessibility. - Additionally, floor drains in walk-in coolers must discharge via indirect waste (air gap) to prevent contamination of stored food (IPC § 802.3.3; FDA Food Code § 5-203.12). - Flagged*: Trap not accessible; likely direct connection — both are code violations.

Summary of likely flags:

  • All three fixtures likely lack required indirect waste (air gap/air break).
  • Cooler drain trap is inaccessible.
  • Grease interceptor connection may be improper if not designed for direct inlet.

Corrective action: Re-pipe all fixtures to discharge via air gap into accessible floor sinks, then drain to sanitary/grease interceptor per IPC Chapter 8. Consult a licensed plumber — this is not a DIY fix before Friday’s inspection. Word count: 248

722 tokens · 5.7s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.